Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour

:iconnaked-in-the-rain: More from naked-in-the-rain

More from deviantART


Submitted on
December 26, 2012
Submitted with Writer


7,796 (2 today)
572 (who?)
please, support this journal with simple :+fav: so more people can see it :heart:

Hello, dear deviants!

Do you want more constructive feedback? You can get it for free.

In order to participate you only have to:

fav this journal


comment on it.

I will make sure I visit your page and comment on one of your deviations, giving it a constructive comment/critique.


one lucky deviant who participates in this project will get 100 points :heart:

Why am I doing this?

I'm trying to show to deviants a real value of good feedback. It's something we should all learn to appreciate, when the comments aren't just pure words like awesome, wow, good, cool...
Deviantart is a big community with many exposed/underexposed artists but all of us are the same when it comes to getting feedback. We all get good and bad.

Nice feedback comment shouldn't be 3000 lines, 35000 characters and what not.
It could be a phrase or two to show our appreciation or suggest something new or better to the author (in our opinion).

Comments such as How did this get on frontpage? (which I agree with sometimes) aren't really a feedback. That is only you not agreeing with dA choices, rules, and deviant's popularity.

When commenting, try to be nice. It doesn't hurt. It won't do anyone harm. Don't play like you know everything in this world, unless you're a professional art critic and you have a reason to think you're helping with your harsh critique. Be down to earth. People are very sensitive when it comes to their art. Support them. Don't hate them and call them names. It's only your loss.

Don't forget that noone's perfect. Noone's art is perfect.
But there's a beauty in every form of it, and if you see it, and you and you and you... the world becomes a better place.


The project is now closed. Thank you all who participated.
We collected 636 participants, which is a great achievement.
The comments are being "processed now".
I will try to give a comment/critique to everyone who participated, just please, be patient.
I will let you know when the project's officially ended, and I will announce the 100 :points: winner in this journal too.
Thank you :heart:

+ if you want more exposure, join us here



The winner is:



feedback project :heart:
Add a Comment:
LuciaTan Jan 1, 2013  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
reaperfoxgirl Dec 28, 2012  Hobbyist Photographer
Comment :meow:
IokoThePanda Dec 28, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
haha, thatīs cool stuff^^

yah, you are thrue, I often write, "Wow, so awesome" ore stuff like that ^^"

But sometimes I write critiques :D
MaxDarkPxP Dec 27, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Thank you |D
AISUReimi Dec 27, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Oh god, I just looked into your gallery, and well... I find your photos quite simple, yet adorable and cute. And I like the paper stuff.
This journal is amazing, the way you'd want to enforce constructive commenting.
I admit, I sometimes comment other people's works just for the sake of commenting, but you somehow made me think twice before doing anything like that again.
Kymira12 Dec 27, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
:wow: 578 people have +fav'd this so far. Don't worry about writing a comment for me. I just wanted to say that this is a fabulous thing you're doing and that I agree with everything that you have written above. I always try to comment/critique but it gets so overwhelming when all that comes to mind is amazing but I never leave comments like that since some would prefer you to say nothing instead of that :shrug:

If you needed some help with the comments/critiques or anything else, I'll be glad to help you :huggle:
Ino-Chii Dec 27, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
What a nice idea!
adamantia3190 Dec 27, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I would appreciate this so much! Especially when it comes to coloring, shading, etc. Thank you!
BubblyTopHat Dec 27, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Such a great idea! Itīs sad that most people are always too lazy to comment :(
I even see amazing artists with almost no comments because everyones too lazy. But i noticed that after about 10 comments the new comments come faster :meow:
Maybe people are too scared when theyīre not in a crowd..... xD
I love this idea! I just joined deviantart, so I would LOVE critiques on my work.
Add a Comment: